urrent Research & Results


Highly localized probing of surface nanomechanical properties with a submicron resolution can be accomplished with scanning probe microscopy (SPM) technique. The SPM ability to probe local surface topography in conjunction with mechanical, adhesive, friction, thermal, magnetic, and electric properties is unique.  We focus on organized molecular films from amphiphilic molecules, molecules with reactive ends and functional oligomers. These films are fabricated by means of Langmuir-Blodgett technique and physical/chemical self-assembly.  The interfacial properties of molecular coatings critical for their lubrication or adhesive performance at a nanoscale are friction forces, shear strength, surface stiffness, compressive elastic behavior, viscoelastic response and adhesive forces. 

Flexible nanomembranes as sensing platform

Nanocomposite LbL membranes

Gold nanoparticles as seen by AFM

Recent reviews:

I. Luzinov, S. Minko, V. V. Tsukruk, Adaptive And Responsive Surfaces Through Controlled Reorganization Of Interfacial Polymer Layers, Prog. Polym. Sci. 2004, 29, 635.

V. V. Tsukruk, V. V. Gorbunov, Nanomechanical Probing With Scanning Force Microscopy, Microscopy Today, 01-1, 8, 2001.

V. V. Tsukruk, Molecular Lubricants And Glues For Micro- and Nanodevices, Adv. Materials, 13, 95, 2001.

Recent highlights:

 

Free-suspended nanocomposite nanomembranes

 

Micropatterned carbon nanotube arrays

 

 

Highlight as an Editors’ Choice in Science, August 29 2003:

 

Stimuli-responsive amphiphilic Y-shaped brush with dissimilar arms attached to a single grafting point (right): switching of surface nanostructures upon treatment with selective solvents (left).

Tsukruk and Zubarev (Iowa State University) demonstrated that spatial constraints imposed by chemical junctions of two dissimilar (hydrophobic and hydrophilic) polymer chains in Y-shaped branched molecules cause the formation of a novel type of switchable nanostructures in brush layers chemically grafted to the silicon surface. The formation of such surface features is caused by chemical junctions of dissimilar arms to a single grafting point. We proposed a model of nano-segregated micelles featuring different states of PS and PAA arms capable of structural reorganization in selective solvents (image). Switching of surface macroscopic properties such as wettability driven by changes in nanoscale structure is of potential interest because resulting nanopatterned morphology can facilitate adaptive nanocoatings and directed assembly of nanoparticles. Such “smart” surfaces hold a great promise in designing of nano-electromechanical, bioanalytical, and microfluidic devices with adaptive properties.

D. Julthongpiput, Y-H. Lin, J. Teng, E. R. Zubarev, V. V. Tsukruk Y-Shaped Polymer Brushes: Nanoscale Switchable Surfaces, Langmuir, 2003, 19, 7832.

 

M. Ornatska, S. E. Jones, R. R. Naik, M. Stone, V. V. Tsukruk 

Biomolecular Stress-Sensitive Gauges: Surface-Mediated Immobilization of Mechanosensitive Membrane Protein,

J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2003, 125, 12722-12723

 

We report the observation of structural reorganizations associated with unique, stress-assisted gating of mechanosensitive (MscL) membrane protein on a silicon surface modified with alkyl-terminated monolayers. We observed that the shape of MscL membrane proteins changed dramatically depending upon the packing density of alkyl tails and the surface tension of the supporting organic layer.  High-resolution atomic force microscopy confirmed a transition from an elongated, prolate shape of MscL molecules within a monolayer with low surface tension to a flattened, oblate shape with a wide central opening within a monolayer with high surface tension. These observations are consistent with the conformation reorganizations associated with the two-stage, iris-like expansion proposed for the gating of the MscL molecules.

 



 

Four generations of amphiphilic dendrons containing a benzyl-15-crown-5 polar focal point, photochromic spacer, and alkyl tails as peripheral groups have been investigated for their ability to form Langmuir monolayers at the air-water interface and on solid surfaces.  The cross-sectional area was found to be proportional to number of alkyl chains for low generations but higher dendrimer generations demonstrate loose packing because of steric hindrances among the branches the outer shells of the dendrons.  Photomechanical behavior of Langmuir monolayers under UV-illumination was observed for intermediate generations with optimal balance between bulky polar heads and dendrimer shells.  We found significant acceleration of photomechanical response during monolayer compression to solid state due to increasing cooperative interactions among photochromic groups.

A. Sidorenko, C. Houphouet-Boigny, O. Villavicencio, M. Hashemzadeh, D. V. McGrath, V. V. Tsukruk, PHOTORESPONSIVE LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS FROM AZOBENZENE-CONTAINING DENDRONS, Langmuir, 2000, 16, 10569.

p-A isotherms for Langmuir monolayers from dendrimers AD0, AD1, AD2, AD3, reference azobenzene compound AH with three tails, and stearic acid (StA)

Rate and amplitude of photomechanical transformations during the illumination of the AD1 monolayer at various surface pressure

 

Molecular structures of isomers of AD0 monodendron. Tilt of mesogenic group increases when trans-cis isomerization occurs.

 

 

SPM topographical and phase images of the monolayers of AH and AD1 dendrons. Vertical scales are 20 nm for AH topography and 5 nm for AD1, 90° for AH phase image and 10° for AD1 phase image. Lateral scale is 5´5 mm. Bright parts correspond to higher elevations 


We present the results of microthermal studies of ultrathin polymeric films deposited on a silicon substrate.  We propose the procedure for microthermal analysis of ultrathin polymer films, elucidate limits of applicability of this technique to study their microthermal properties, and observe thermomechanical response during local heating for films with thickness above 10 nm.  The glass transition temperature of ultrathin PS films deduced from experiments decreases for film thickness below 200 nm.  For the thinnest PS film with clearly detectable response (25 nm), glass transition temperature is 20oC below its bulk value.  Our estimation of heat dissipation in the tip-surface contact area supports conclusion that observed micro-thermal-analysis (μTA) response for polymer films is associated mainly with temperature induced elastic variation of the contact area. 

V. V. Gorbunov, N. Fuchigami, I. Luzinov, V. V. Tsukruk, Microthermal Probing Of Ultrathin Polymer Films, High Performance Polymers, 12, 603, 2000.

 

A sketch of the SThM detection scheme for ultrathin film measurements

µTMA results for bulk polymers used as reference samples for temperature calibration

 

The variation of its glass transition temperature as probed with µTMA of the PS films with different thickness on a silicon substrate


We fabricated robust ultrathin film of a tri-block copolymer, poly[styrene – b - (ethylene-co-butylene) - b- styrene] (SEBS), functionalized with 2% of maleic anhydride by melt/solution grafting to a chemically reactive silicon surface.  The thickness of grafted block-polymer, t, was varied from 1.35 nm to 9.1 nm to test and the ratio t/d was changed from 0.05 to 0.33, where d is the interdomain spacing.  The contact angle measurements demonstrated that the surface of the complete block copolymer films was totally occupied by poly[ethylene-co-butene] (PEB) chains.  When the SEBS film thickness reached 8.4 nm, the film possessed the well-defined microphase structure of the typical thermoplastic elastomer material, where PS phase formed the microdomain network that reinforced the elastomeric matrix.  The microphase separation was completely suppressed only for ultrathin films with t/d < 0.08.  We found that tethered monolayers were extremely stable and preserved their microdomain structure at elevated temperatures unlike spincoated films that dewetted under similar conditions.

 

 

Microstructure of grafted SEBS layer

 

Luzinov, D. Julthongpiput, V. V. Tsukruk, Thermoplastic Elastomer Monolayers Grafted to a Silicon Substrate, Macromolecules, 33, 7629, 2000

I. Luzinov, D. Julthongpiput, V. V. Tsukruk, Stability Of Microdomain Morphology In Tethered Block-Polymer Monolayers, Polymer, 42, 2267, 2001.

Wear resistance test for grafted (left) and spin-coated (right) polymer films

Nanodomain structure of 8 nm thick grafted SEBS layer


Scanning thermal microscopy (SThM) is used for the probing microthermal surface properties of a wide range of materials ranging from low thermally conductive polymers to highly conductive metals.  We demonstrate the unique capability of SThM technique in measuring microthermal surface conductivity.  We discuss the detail experimental procedure for the microthermal measurement including the selection of the probing parameters for different surfaces, data collection, and data processing.  We propose and test the relationships for the evaluation of the thermal probe heat dissipation and the surface temperature variation during approaching-retracing microprobing.  For the direct thermal probe-surface contact, a linear relationship is demonstrated between the probe heat dissipation and the initial temperature gradient that opens the way for the direct estimation of the absolute value of the surface thermal conductivity.

We proposed the procedure for the evaluation of the surface thermal conductivity from the microthermal probing with scanning thermal microscopy (SThM).  This approach is based on the theory of a steady heat transfer between the thermal tip and a surface.  The variation of the surface microthermal conductivity as measured by SThM correlates fairly well with known bulk materials values.  We used the model of the quasi-steady heat transfer between the thermal tip and the surface to interpret our experimental results obtained in part I (Gorbunov et al, 2000).  This model describes the observed increase of the heat dissipation of the thermal probe approaching the surface due to the temperature gradient presented on a surface before the probe-surface physical contact.  The model predicts that there is a lower limit for the thermal probe velocity for obtaining meaningful thermal data.  Higher sensitivity of the microthermal probing can be achieved by increasing probe velocity and by using positional/temperature modulation.

V. V. Gorbunov, N. Fuchigami, J. L. Hazel, V. V. Tsukruk, Microprobing Surface Thermal Properties By Scanning Thermal Microscopy, Langmuir, 1999, V15, N24, p.8340-8343

V. V. Gorbunov, N. Fuchigami, V. V. Tsukruk, Microthermal Analysis With Scanning Thermal Microscopy. I. Methodology and Experimental, Probe Microscopy, 2, 53, 2000.

V. V. Gorbunov, N. Fuchigami, V. V. Tsukruk, Microthermal Analysis With Scanning Thermal Microcopy. II: Calibration, Modeling, and Interpretation. Probe Microscopy, 2, 65, 2000.

A sketch of the SThM detection scheme and tip-surface approaching and retracting data for gold and polystyrene surfaces showing difference in heat dissipation jump at the point of physical contact.

 

 

Thermal image (right) and topography (left) for 15 x 15 µm silicon oxide-silicon grid.

 

 


Dense, homogeneous, and complete self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) with epoxy surface groups were fabricated from epoxysilanes to serve as a template for chemical anchoring of polymer layers.  Epoxysilane SAMs were truly monomolecular films with a virtually normal molecular orientation of densely packed molecules, which were firmly attached to the substrate.  Carboxylic acid and anhydride-terminated polystyrenes of different molecular weights from 4500 to 672000 were grafted from melt onto silicon substrates modified with epoxysilane monolayer.  The grafted chains are densely packed with a density close to the known value for the bulk material.  The tethered polymer layers are very smooth, uniform, mechanically stable, and cover homogeneously the modified silicon.  At the degree of polymerization (N) close to the critical molecular weight, the grafting process is the most effective resulting in the grafted unperturbed macromolecules.  We suggest that the grafting from the reactive polymer melt is controlled by steric constrains through the minimum available free volume between the grafted macromolecules, which is reachable by another reactive end. 

V. V. Tsukruk, I. Luzinov, D. Julthongpiput, Sticky Molecular Surfaces: Epoxysilane Self-Assembled Monolayers, Langmuir, 1999, 15, 3029. 

I. Luzinov, D. Julthongpiput, H. Malz, J. Pionteck, V. V. Tsukruk, Polystyrene Layers Grafted To Epoxy-Modified Silicon Surfaces, Macromolecules, 33, 1043, 2000.


We fabricated and studied several sets of composite molecular films such as self-assembled monolayers and fullerene molecules, complexes of fatty acids and rigid polymers (ladder polymers, polyimides). Their structural ordering and microtribological properties were studied in comparison with classic boundary lubricants by AFM/FFM. We suggested the characterization of the organic layers with a figure of merit parameter introduced through the friction coefficient normalized to the maximum limits of dissipated energy. Correlation between this parameter and a packing density of the monolayers was found.

 

V. N. Bliznyuk, et al. "Nanotribological properties of organic boundary lubricants: Langmuir films versus self-assembled monolayers" J. Tribology, October, 120, 489, 1998


Self-assembly of polymer (grafted polymer, polyelectrolyte, and dendrimer) layers was studied. Nano- and micro-phase separated structures were observed for mixed monolayers. Organized multilayer films from globular dendritic macromolecules were fabricated and characterized.

V. V.Tsukruk, et al. "Miscibility and segregated structures in mixed polymer monolayers", Supramolecular Sciences, 2, 219, 1995; V. V. Tsukruk "Dendritic Macromolecules at Interfaces", Advanced Matl., 10, 253, 1998

 

 

 


SPM was used for probing nanomechanical properties of compliant polymeric materials. Sneddon’s, Hertzian, and Johnson-Kendall-Roberts theories of elastic contacts were tested for a variety of polymeric materials, ranging from very compliant rubbers (e.g., natural rubber) to hard glassy polymers (e.g., polystyrene). All models of elastic contact allowed microprobing depth profile and gave consistent values of elastic moduli.

S. A. Chizhik, Z. Huang, V. V. Gorbunov, N. K. Myshkin, V. V. Tsukruk, Micromechanical Properties Of Elastic Polymeric Materials As Probed By Scanning Force Microscopy, Langmuir, 14, 2606, 1998.

V. V. Tsukruk, V. V. Gorbunov, Z. Huang, S. A. Chizhik, Dynamic Microprobing Of Viscoelastic Polymer Properties, Polymer Intern. 49, 441, 2000.